S. Jay Olshansky and Bruce A.
Carnes (1997)
Ever Since Gompertz
Gompertz: derived a formula (in 1825) describing the exponential rise
in death rates between sexual maturity and old age. Began the search
for a law of mortality to describe common patterns of senescence.
This is a review/overview of his and subsequent work.
Gompertz’s Law of Mortality
-
Linked arithmetic increases in age with geometric increases in death rates
-
The “power to oppose destruction” diminishes as a constant (equal amount
over equal time)
-
Sought a biological explanation: discussed a “hypothetical life force”
that destroyed life, and tried to factor that into actuarial calculations
-
Chance: the primary or essential element in the cause of death…increased
by the diminution of the vital life force…explains why constant quantity
of the “vital force” could be varying
Makeham’s Theory of Partial Forces of Mortality (directly building
on Gompertz)
-
Observed accelerated increases in the force of mortality at older relative
to younger ages (3)
-
Looked at diseases impacting specific organs (i.e. biological explanations
of morality)…the diseases studied thrive on the diminution of vital forces
-
The “partitioning” was in reference to examining both extrinsic and intrinsic
mortality
The Historical Search for a Law of Mortality (*an odd historical
overview—worth skipping)
-
Extended the law to all species, assuming differences among species were
just a matter of scale
-
Looked at specific chemical reactions and major elements of the “life table”
(like carbon dating)…“time dependent decay” comparable to Gompertz’s idea
on the loss of vital forces
-
Random dudes found humans lived longer and attributed it to control over
the environment
-
Others (including Makeham) questioned the law of mortality primarily because
of the “inability to partition total mortality into its intrinsic and extrinsic
causes of death” (5)
Biodemography
-
Trying to discover “dying out patterns”…why does death occur when it does
in individuals?
“Why does the risk of death decline to its lowest point at sexual maturity
for amy species, and thereafter incrase along a predictable path?” (6)
-
Gompertz and Makeham set the stage for improved methods…for example, radiation
exposure to test “accelerated senescence” (6) --> significant because it
was a physiologically based level of analysis…led to the lethality function
calculated for species exposed
-
“The modern evolutionary theory of senescence is based on the premise that
selection is effective in altering gene frequencies until the time before
the end of the reproductive period” (9). The future is in genetics
and demography
Non-Gompertizian Mortality at Older Ages
-
Discussion of how Gompertz and Makeham’s work did/does not apply to older
ages --> recognition of its inadequacy has led some to unwisely discount
it completely
-
Facts re: “non-Gompertizian mortality in certain regions of the life span
(1-3 on pp. 10-11)
Conclusion
-
Gompertz equation/distribution one of the major quantitative tools used
in analyzing failure times for living and mechanical organisms…his law
of mortality and biological roots verified
-
See conceptual framework for intrinsic mortality within biodemography:
b12L to t12R